22 September 2020>: Meta-Analysis
Prevalence and Prevention of Reproducibility Deficiencies in Life Sciences Research: Large-Scale Meta-Analyses
Nadine M. Mansour 12ABCDEF , E. Andrew Balas 1ACDE* , Frances M. Yang 3CDE , Marlo M. Vernon 4BCEFDOI: 10.12659/MSM.922016
Med Sci Monit 2020; 26:e922016
Table 1 Baseline characteristics of the included studies.
Author | Year | Country | Deficiency Group | Sample type | Size | Author | Year | Country | Deficiency Group | Sample type | Size |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Armstrong []25 | 2010 | USA | Mycoplasma contamination | Human & animal cell cultures | 38225 | Mariotti []26 | 2008 | Italy | Mycoplasma contamination & misidentification | Human & animal cell lines | 37 |
Avram []27 | 1985 | USA | Design, statistics, & reporting | Anesthesia articles | 243 | McGarrity []28 | 1986 | USA | Mycoplasma contamination | Cell cultures | 2589 |
Azari []29 | 2007 | Iran | Misidentification | Human cell lines | 100 | McGuigan []30 | 1995 | UK | Design, statistics, & reporting | Psychiatry research articles | 164 |
Berglind []31 | 2008 | Sweden | Misidentification | Human cancer cell lines | 384 | McKinney []32 | 1989 | USA | Design, statistics, & reporting | Medical research articles | 56 |
Bölske []33 | 1988 | Sweden | Mycoplasma contamination | Cell cultures | 1424 | Mirjalili []34 | 2005 | Iran | Mixed contamination | Human and animal cell lines | 138 |
Capes-Davis []14 | 2010 | Australia | Misidentification | Human cell lines | 360 | Neville []35 | 2006 | USA | Design, statistics, & reporting | Dermatology research articles | 155 |
Capes-Davis []36 | 2013 | Australia | Misidentification | Human cell lines | 1157 | Nour-Eldein []37 | 2016 | Egypt | Design, statistics, & reporting | Medical Research articles | 60 |
Cobo []38 | 2007 | Spain | Mixed contamination | Stem cell cultures | 151 | Olarerin-George []39 | 2015 | USA | Mycoplasma contamination | Human & animal cell cultures | 484 |
Didion []40 | 2014 | USA | Cross-, mixed contamination, & misidentification | Mouse cell lines | 99 | Oliver []41 | 1989 | Australia | Design, statistics, & reporting | Surgery research articles | 240 |
Drexler []42 | 1999 | Germany | Cross-contamination | Human hematopoietic cell lines | 189 | Onwuegbuzie []43 | 2002 | USA | Design, statistics, & reporting | Educational Research | 36 |
Drexler []15 | 2002 | Germany | Contamination, cross-contamination, & false | Human leukemia lymphoma cell lines | 1404 | Patel []44 | 2014 | India | Design, statistics, & reporting | Basic Medical articles | 128 |
Drexler []45 | 2003 | Germany | Misidentification | Human leukemia lymphoma cell lines | 550 | Pienkowska []46 | 1998 | Canada | Viral contamination | Human cell lines | 75 |
Drexler []47 | 2010 | Germany | Mycoplasma contamination & misidentification | Human leukemia lymphoma cell lines | 1331 | Pilčèk []48 | 2003 | Czech | Design, statistics, & reporting | Biomedical articles | 171 |
Drexler []49 | 2017 | Germany | Mycoplasma contamination & misidentification | Human leukemia lymphoma cell lines | 330 | Roulland-Dussoix []50 | 1994 | France | Mycoplasma contamination | Cell cultures | 372 |
Ercan []51 | 2012 | Turkey | Design, statistics, & reporting | Medical sciences articles | 181 | Schweppe []52 | 2008 | USA | Misidentification | Human thyroid cancer cell lines | 40 |
Ercan []53 | 2015 | Turkey | Design, statistics, & reporting | Medical sciences articles | 217 | Šimundić []54 | 2009 | Croatia | Design, statistics, & reporting | Medical research articles | 55 |
Ercan []55 | 2017 | Turkey | Design, statistics, & reporting | Veterinary sciences articles | 204 | Spierenburg []56 | 1988 | Netherlands | Mycoplasma contamination | Animal cell lines | 115 |
Felson []57 | 1984 | USA | Design, statistics, & reporting | Rheumatology research articles | 74 | Störmer []58 | 2009 | Germany | Mycoplasma contamination | Human cell lines | 176 |
Hanif []59 | 2011 | Pakistan | Design, statistics, & reporting | Medical sciences articles | 80 | Strasak []60 | 2007 | Austria | Design, statistics, & reporting | Medical sciences articles | 15 |
Hassan []61 | 2015 | India | Design, statistics, & reporting | Medical research articles | 2012 | Strasak []62 | 2007 | Austria | Design, statistics, & reporting | Medical sciences articles | 53 |
Hopert []63 | 1993 | Germany | Mycoplasma contamination | Continuous cell lines | 42 | Teyssou []64 | 1993 | France | Mycoplasma contamination | Animal cell cultures | 82 |
Huang []65 | 2017 | China | Misidentification & cross-contamination | Tumor cell lines | 278 | Timenetsky []66 | 2006 | Brazil | Mycoplasma contamination | Human cell cultures | 301 |
Hué []67 | 2010 | UK | Viral contamination | Human cell lines | 411 | Uchio-Yamada []68 | 2017 | Japan | Misidentification | Mouse cell lines | 80 |
Hukku []69 | 1984 | USA | Mixed contamination | Cell cultures | 275 | Uphoff []70 | 2002 | Germany | Mycoplasma contamination | Leukemia lymphoma cell lines | 451 |
Ishikawa []71 | 2006 | Japan | Mycoplasma contamination | Cell cultures | 337 | Uphoff []72 | 2010 | Germany | Viral contamination | Animal cell lines | 465 |
Jin []73 | 2010 | China | Design, statistics, & reporting | Medical research articles | 2913 | Uphoff []74 | 2015 | Germany | Viral contamination | Human cell lines | 577 |
Jung []75 | 2003 | USA | Mycoplasma contamination | Human & animal+ cell lines | 15 | Van Kuppeveld []76 | 1994 | Netherlands | Mycoplasma contamination | Human & animal cell cultures | 95 |
Kazemiha []77 | 2009 | Iran | Mycoplasma contamination | Mammalian cell lines | 200 | Welch II []78 | 2002 | USA | Design, statistics, & reporting | OB/GYN research articles | 195 |
Kazemiha []79 | 2014 | Iran | Mycoplasma contamination | Human and animal cell lines | 40 | Welch []80 | 1996 | USA | Design, statistics, & reporting | OB/GYN research articles | 145 |
Korch []81 | 2012 | USA | Misidentification | Endometrial & ovarian cancer | 51 | Wu []82 | 2011 | China | Design, statistics, & reporting | Medical research articles | 2145 |
Kurichi []83 | 2006 | USA | Design, statistics, & reporting | Surgery research articles | 187 | Ye []84 | 2015 | China | Cross-contamination | Human cell lines | 380 |
Lucena []22 | 2011 | Spain | Design, statistics, & reporting | Dentistry research studies | 226 | Yim []85 | 2010 | Korea | Design, statistics, & reporting | Medical research articles | 139 |
MacArthur []86 | 1984 | USA | Design, statistics, & reporting | Medical sciences articles | 64 | Yoshino []87 | 2006 | Japan | Misidentification | Human cell lines | 400 |
MacLeod []88 | 1999 | Germany | Cross-contamination | Human tumor cell lines | 252 | Zhao []89 | 2011 | USA | Cross-contamination | Human cell lines | 122 |