Logo Medical Science Monitor

Call: +1.631.470.9640
Mon - Fri 10:00 am - 02:00 pm EST

Contact Us

Logo Medical Science Monitor Logo Medical Science Monitor Logo Medical Science Monitor

23 August 2022: Meta-Analysis

Optimal Surgical Treatment Method for Anterior Cruciate Ligament Rupture: Results from a Network Meta-Analysis

Yudi Wu 1CDEF , Yajia Li 2BCD , Jia Guo 2BC , Qiangxiang Li 34BC , Jianhuang Wu 35BCD , Ziqin Cao 5ABCDEF* , Yulin Song 6ABCDEF*

DOI: 10.12659/MSM.937118

Med Sci Monit 2022; 28:e937118

Table 1 Baseline characteristics of included studies.

AuthorNo.YearNumber of patientsMean ageMale/FemaleTraumatic mechanismSurgery methodMean follow-up (months)Study designControl intervention IControl intervention IIControl intervention III
Gagliardi AG et al []31 1201917915.4887/92Low-energy trauma 164High-energy trauma 0Arthroscopy36.0Cohort studyAutograftRepair with augmentation/
Meunier A et al []39 2200710021.4468/32NRArthroscopy180.0Randomized clinical trialRepair with augmentationRepair without augmentationAutograft
Hoogeslag RAG et al []19 320194821.5013820NRArthroscopy24.0Randomized clinical trialRepair with augmentationAutograft/
Achtnich A et al []27 420164031.80NRNRArthroscopy28.0Non-randomized clinical trialRepair without augmentationAutograft/
Bottoni CR et al []29 520159729.0584/13Low-energy trauma 98High-energy trauma 2Arthroscopy120.0Randomized clinical trialAutograftNon-irradiated allograft/
Sporsheim AN et al []44 6201915029.0036/28NRArthroscopy360.0Randomized clinical trialRepair without augmentationRepair with augmentationAutograft
Sun K et al []46 720099930.5570/29Low-energy trauma 88High-energy trauma 10Arthroscopy31.0Randomized clinical trialAutograftNon-irradiated allograftIrradiated allograft
Murray MM et al []41 8202010017.0044/56NRArthroscopy24.0Randomized clinical trialRepair without augmentationAutograft/
Schliemann B et al []43 920176028.6523/37NRArthroscopy12.0Randomized clinical trialRepair with augmentationAutograft/
Wang HD et al []52 1020175732.7019/38NRArthroscopy36.0Cohort studyHybridAutograft/
Murray MM et al []40 1120162024.356/14Low-energy trauma 19High-energy trauma 1Arthroscopy3.0Cohort studyRepair without augmentationAutograft/
Edgar CM et al []30 1220088329.2246/37NRArthroscopy50.0Cohort studyAutograftNon-irradiated allograft/
Li J et al []37 1320168031.3750/30NRArthroscopy67.2Randomized clinical trialAutograftIrradiated allograftHybrid
Kösters C et al []34 1420208528.1656/29NRArthroscopy24.0Randomized clinical trialRepair with augmentationAutograft/
Sun K et al []60 15200915632.26124/32Low-energy trauma 154High-energy trauma 2Arthroscopy67.2Randomized clinical trialAutograftNon-irradiated allograft/
Sun K et al []47 1620096524.8917/48Low-energy trauma 61High-energy trauma 4Arthroscopy31.0Randomized clinical trialAutograftIrradiated allograft/
Sun K et al []48 1720116730.6015/52Low-energy trauma 61High-energy trauma 4Arthroscopy42.2Randomized clinical trialAutograftIrradiated allograft/
Sun K et al []58 18201118630.42149/37Low-energy trauma 61High-energy trauma 8Arthroscopy93.0Randomized clinical trialAutograftNon-irradiated allograft/
Jia YH et al []33 19201510629.5054/52NRArthroscopy81.0Randomized clinical trialNon-irradiated allograftAutograft/
Tian S et al []50 20201612130.2196/25Low-energy trauma 113High-energy trauma 8Arthroscopy55.2Randomized clinical trialAutograftNon-irradiated allograft/
Tian S et al []49 2120168328.8966/17Low-energy trauma 77High-energy trauma 6Arthroscopy82.8Randomized clinical trialAutograftIrradiated allograft/
Yoo SH et al []54 22201513227.09120/12NRArthroscopy33.6Randomized clinical trialAutograftNon-irradiated allograft/
Tian S et al []51 2320106931.2556/13Low-energy trauma 60High-energy trauma 9Arthroscopy38.5Randomized clinical trialAutograftIrradiated allograft/
Bi HY et al []28 2420138632.0060/26NRArthroscopy38.5Randomized clinical trialAutograftNon-irradiated allograft/
Sun K et al []45 2520045332.3444/9NRArthroscopy19.0Randomized clinical trialAutograftNon-irradiated allograft/
Gorschewsky O et al []32 26200220132.97150/51NRArthroscopy24.0Randomized clinical trialAutograftNon-irradiated allograft/
Li J et al []38 2720159530.6250/45Low-energy trauma 87High-energy trauma 8Arthroscopy71.2Randomized clinical trialAutograftIrradiated allograftHybrid
Murray MM et al []18 2820192024.356/14Low-energy trauma 19High-energy trauma 1Arthroscopy24.0Cohort studyRepair without augmentationAutograft/
Darnley JE et al []56 2920165420.9034/20NRArthroscopy24.0Cohort studyAutograftHybrid/
Zheng X et al []55 3020199730.7769/28NRArthroscopy20.1Randomized clinical trialAutograftHybridIrradiated allograft
Kraeutler MJ et al []35 31201714833.78NRNRArthroscopy50.1Randomized clinical trialAutograftHybrid/
Pennock AT et al []42 3220164015.6515/25NRArthroscopy24.0Non-randomized clinical trialHybridAutograft/
Leo BM et al []36 3320169527.2060/35NRArthroscopy24.0Non-randomized clinical trialAutograftHybrid/
Xu H et al []59 3420187635.6652/24Low-energy trauma 67High-energy trauma 9Arthroscopy27.0Cohort studyAutograftHybrid/
Burrus MT et al []57 3520155826.9020/38NRArthroscopy46.2Non-randomized clinical trialHybridAutograft/
Xu H et al []53 3620176833.9043/25NRArthroscopy24.0Non-randomized clinical trialAutograftHybrid/

Your Privacy

We use cookies to ensure the functionality of our website, to personalize content and advertising, to provide social media features, and to analyze our traffic. If you allow us to do so, we also inform our social media, advertising and analysis partners about your use of our website, You can decise for yourself which categories you you want to deny or allow. Please note that based on your settings not all functionalities of the site are available. View our privacy policy.

Medical Science Monitor eISSN: 1643-3750
Medical Science Monitor eISSN: 1643-3750